CHAPTER 3. THE INFLATION "SPIRAL"
Discussion of structural and institutional factors contributing to the "spiral feedback", where cause & effect are linked in "chicken/egg", "momentum" aspects of inflation; preceded by summary list of initial erogenous causes to be discussed elsewhere.
INTRODUCTION: Interaction of syndromes (define syndromes sufficiently that no sub-intro'd needed below). (see "net result" at end)
- "Catch-up" Syndromes: "Defensive"
- Cost-of-living adjustments (COLA's) and price "indexation". (Brazil?)
- Explicit contractual COLA'S.
- Invidious relationships: "market-induced" COLA's to maintain "normal" income relationships
- Why both are illusory.
desire vs. ability
(wages, interest rates)
- Cost-plus-fixed-profit-margin pricing practices.
- Money supply growth rate (M2.1, 2.2) (But see policy syndromes)
- Speculative Syndromes: anticipation (both "defensive" and "offensive")
- Inflation expectations & "buy now before the price goes up" attitude -Consumers and Business
- Speculative bidding-up of the prices of real estate, commodities, and
collectibles (speculative hoarding creates real market shortages, double ordering, longer delivery time, a seller's-market increase in prices, credit financing of commodity speculation).
- Effect on borrowing
- Interest rates
- Two mechanisms:
- inflation premium
- speculative real demand
- "Spiral": credit demand, interest rates, interest cost, inflation rate (MR-6A).
- Delayed cumulative effect as more contracts are written at higher rates.
- Exchange rates.
- Anticipation of price/wage "freeze" & subsequent controls ever since Carter elected.
- The Tax-in-COLA Syndrome
- Conflicting purposes of COLAs and the taxes which directly affect the CPI
- Tax payments as an indirect part of our STANDARD of living, rather than COST of living.
- Effect-on CPI of kind-of-tax shift (since some taxes affect prices & others not).
- The Savings-in-COLA Syndrome
- Inappropriate COLA Price Index Syndrome
- Inflation bias of CPI
- Biased market basket.
- Structural Syndromes: where the fact of inflation causes a change in
structural relationships, which has secondary inflationary effects.
- Reduction of bargaining power of consumer & industrial buyers by destruction of comparison-shopping standards of reference for distinguishing between fair prices, bargains, and rip-offs.
- Loss of sellers' standard of reference for what is a "fair" or "sound" profit target (short-run "take all the traffic will bear" attitude when a general feeling exists that things are out of control).
- Effect-of inflation on profits (as a target for wages).
- Inflation adjustment for "real" profits --but capital gains real (compare to housing appreciation). (Example of executive bonuses)
- Diversion of entrepreneurial effort towards a search for quick speculative profits and away from economically productive activity (which tens to reduce the growth of productivity.
- No solid basis left for long-run business investment planning.
- "Two-tier" markets: cat food for the old, Cadillacs for the rich (stimulation of conspicuous consumption of high-price-and-profit-margin luxury goods and services-- big cars, fancy restaurants, NYT ads --by those who gain from inflation. (example of executive pay)
- Effect of housing turnover on debt/asset ratios & overall credit balance.
- Effect of inflation on net borrowing in relation to current saving -- borrowing financed by increase in income of wealthy.
- CPI biases-- change in market basket as result of inflation
- Hospital costs--higher costs lead to more complete insurance, which reduces cost-cutting incentives, encourages hospitals to provide more extensive and expensive health care facilities.
- The sharper the increase in prices, the worse the structural effect (ex. wheat-land prices, oil & profits)
- Increasing concentration of wealth & income.
- Policy Syndromes: where inappropriate anti-inflation policies exacerbate inflation.
- Federal budget cutting which reduces productivity and increases future costs.
- Oil price controls (= 5 extra years of gas guzzlers & excessive foreign car imports) (True of all inappropriate price & wage controls, where controls tend to reduce supply &/or increase demand. These are the market distortions emphasized by opponents of controls.)
- Complex Interactions
- OPEC price increases reduce ORE & GNP = reduced productivity & increased labor costs.
"Net result": The longer the inflation is allowed to continue, the harder it is to stop, because of increase in built-in costs (e.g. interest payments) -- reason for "freeze" and controls. Gradualist approach ("patience") won't work without terrible distortions and inequities.